Skip to main content

Theresa C. Carnegie

Member

[email protected]

+1.202.661.8710

Follow:
Share:

"Theresa has exceptional knowledge and expertise. She is creative and a highly effective negotiator."

— Health Care Client, Chambers USA 2025

Theresa is a nationally recognized health care and pharmaceutical supply chain attorney who advises clients on PBM strategy, drug pricing, and the regulatory and transactional issues shaping the pharmaceutical industry. With more than 25 years of experience, she combines sophisticated legal judgment with deep industry insight to help clients navigate complex commercial, regulatory, and policy environments.

Theresa has extensive experience structuring, drafting, and negotiating transactions across the pharmaceutical supply chain, including PBM service agreements, retail, mail, and specialty pharmacy arrangements, pharmaceutical purchase and distribution agreements, GPO arrangements, and rebate and value-based contracting models. She regularly advises clients on reimbursement structures, drug pricing strategy, and compliance with federal and state fraud and abuse laws.

Her practice spans health care transactions and investment matters, where she represents clients in mergers, private equity and venture capital investments, and strategic collaborations. Theresa supports regulatory diligence, licensing, change-of-ownership filings, and risk assessment across complex health care and pharmaceutical supply chain deals.

Theresa counsels PBMs, health plans, pharmacies, and distribution stakeholders on operational, regulatory, and compliance matters across commercial, Medicare Advantage, Part D, and multistate health care markets. She helps clients evaluate structural design considerations, policy developments, and business opportunities associated with innovation in drug delivery, reimbursement, and emerging service models.

Recognized as an industry thought leader, Theresa frequently communicates timely updates on regulatory, policy, and market developments affecting clients in the pharmaceutical supply chain. She is a regular author and speaker on health care regulatory and PBM-related issues.

Theresa is a member of the firm's Policy Committee.

Experience

  • Represented LucyRx, a Summit Partners portfolio company and next-generation pharmacy benefit manager, in connection with multiple strategic growth initiatives, including its strategic combination with Abarca Health, acquisitions of CerpassRx, Integrated Prescription Management (IPM), and HealthSmart’s PBM business, and a strategic PBM affiliation with CitizensRx.
  • Represented Cigna as health regulatory counsel in its acquisition of Express Scripts.
  • Represented Catamaran (f/k/a CatalystRx) in the structuring and negotiation of its PBM services arrangement with CIGNA.
  • Represented national worker’s compensation PBM in connection with multiple workers' compensation PBM acquisitions.
  • Represented a national specialty pharmacy provider in connection with an internal compliance audit and investigation and response to government investigation.
  • Advised national pharmacy chain in multiple specialty pharmacy and long-term care pharmacy acquisitions.
  • Represented SingleCare, a discount medical and pharmacy card operator (DMPO), in its contracting with pharmacies, providers, and other vendors.
  • Served as regulatory counsel to a consortium of investors led by TPG Capital and Welsh, Carson, Anderson & Stowe in their $4.1 billion acquisition of Kindred Healthcare, Inc. (NYSE: KND). The transaction was recognized by The Deal as the 2018 Private Equity Deal of the Year.
  • Advised a global health care company on a variety of issues in connection with its acquisition of several health plans and provider groups, including health care regulatory due diligence, health care regulatory advice regarding transaction structure and strategy, and preparation of regulatory notices and other filings.
  • Advised national pharmacy chain in connection with government agency arrangement to provide accessible COVID-19 testing.
Read less

viewpoints

Federal Court Issues Preliminary Injunction Against Iowa PBM Law, Citing ERISA Preemption and First Amendment Violations

July 23, 2025 | Blog | By Rachel A. Alexander, Theresa Carnegie, David Gilboa, Abdie Santiago

U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa issued a comprehensive preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of key provisions of Iowa Senate File 383.

Read more

Federal Court Temporarily Halts Iowa’s PBM Reform Law Amid Legal Challenges

July 8, 2025 | Blog | By Rachel A. Alexander, Theresa Carnegie, David Gilboa, Abdie Santiago

On June 11, 2025, Iowa enacted Senate File 383 (the “Act”), a comprehensive bill aimed at regulating pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) with the stated goals of increasing transparency, supporting independent pharmacies, and reducing prescription drug costs. However, on June 30, 2025, just one day before the Act’s effective date, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa issued a temporary restraining order (TRO), enjoining enforcement of the Act against the lawsuit’s named plaintiffs. The court found that the plaintiffs, a coalition of Iowa employers and ERISA-governed health plans, demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits of their claims that the Act is preempted by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and violates the First Amendment. The lawsuit aligns with other recent challenges against similar comprehensive legislation and further demonstrates the long-lasting conflict between PBM reform legislation and preemption by federal law.

Read more

PBM Policy and Legislative Update — Spring 2025

June 10, 2025 | Blog | By Rachel A. Alexander, Theresa Carnegie, Tara E. Dwyer, Lauren Moldawer, Bridgette Keller, Pamela Polevoy, Madison Castle, David Gilboa, Xavier Hardy, Samantha Hawkins, Stephnie John, Alison H. Peters, Abdie Santiago, Hassan Shaikh, Sophia Temis, Payton Thornton

The PBM Policy and Legislative Update — Spring 2025 edition builds upon prior issues and summarizes activity from January through March (2025) that affects the PBM industry. It highlights federal activities, state activities, and other noteworthy events and trends affecting the PBM industry.

Read more

PBMs Sue Arkansas over Restrictive PBM Ownership Law

June 9, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Hassan Shaikh, Samantha Hawkins, Mitchell Clough

On April 16, 2025, Arkansas enacted Act 624 (the Act), an unprecedented law prohibiting pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) from owning or operating pharmacies in the state. As we discussed in our May 2025 blog post, the law’s passage has already resulted in market disruptions, and PBMs with vertically integrated business models have cautioned that the law will limit patients’ access to drugs and cost many local jobs. 

Now, two of the nation’s largest PBMs, CVS Health and Cigna’s Express Scripts (ESI), have filed federal lawsuits seeking to block implementation of the Act on the grounds that the Act is unconstitutional, preempted by federal law, and harmful to Arkansans. 

Read more

Trump Signs Most-Favored-Nation Executive Order - Potential Impact on Drug Supply Chain

May 14, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Lauren Moldawer, Bridgette Keller, Sophia Temis

President Trump issued his “Delivering Most-Favored Nation Prescription Drug Pricing to American Patients” Executive Order (Executive Order) this week.  The Executive Order seeks to reduce the price of drugs by requiring manufacturers to offer the United States most-favored-nation pricing, or in other words, the lowest price offered to any “comparably developed” foreign country that pays for the same drugs. 

Read more

Arkansas Law Takes Unprecedented Step to Prohibit PBM Ownership of Pharmacies

May 6, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Hassan Shaikh, Samantha Hawkins

Arkansas Governor signed Act 624 on April 16, 2025, banning PBMs from acquiring or holding a direct or indirect interest in a pharmacy. This state-led move may inspire similar laws elsewhere.

Read more

Trump Administration Issues Drug Pricing Executive Order

April 30, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Xavier Hardy, Samantha Hawkins, Abdie Santiago

On April 15, 2025, President Trump issued an Executive Order instructing federal agencies to implement a variety of drug pricing reforms. The Executive Order addresses drug pricing from several different angles, including pharmacy benefit manager (“PBM”) competition and transparency, Medicare and Medicaid drug pricing, international importation, and drug manufacturer competition (the “Executive Order”).

The Executive Order, which is the first significant action taken by the current Administration to address drug prices, echoes initiatives and policy statements announced during the first Trump Administration. However, most of the drug pricing reforms announced during the first Administration were never fully implemented. It is unclear how many of the proposals in this Executive Order will ultimately be implemented, but it does provide the clearest outline yet of the Administration’s policy priorities regarding drug prices.

Read more

Mintz IRA Update — Fourth Edition: Q1 2025

February 13, 2025 | Article | By Rachel A. Alexander, Theresa Carnegie, Tara E. Dwyer, Lauren Moldawer, Hassan Shaikh, Stephnie John, Madison Castle, Mitchell Clough, Xavier Hardy, Samantha Hawkins, Alexander Hecht, Abdie Santiago

Mintz’s Pharmacy Benefits and PBM Contracting Practice is pleased to present the ‘Fourth Edition: Q1 2025’ of our Mintz IRA Update, a regular publication that delves into developments of the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) and their impact on pharmaceutical supply chain stakeholders.

Read more

PBM Policy and Legislative Update — Winter 2025

February 10, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Tara E. Dwyer, Rachel A. Alexander, Lauren Moldawer, Bridgette Keller, Priyanka Amirneni, Madison Castle, David Gilboa, Xavier Hardy, Samantha Hawkins, Stephnie John, Alison H. Peters, Pamela Polevoy, Abdie Santiago, Hassan Shaikh, Sophia Temis

The PBM Policy and Legislative Update — Winter 2025 edition builds upon prior PBM Policy and Legislative Updates and summarizes activity from October through December (2024) that affects the PBM industry. It highlights (i) federal activities, (ii) state activities, and (iii) other noteworthy events and trends affecting the PBM industry.

Read more

Massachusetts Aligns with National Trends and Enacts Sweeping Legislation to Regulate Pharmaceutical Benefit Managers

January 24, 2025 | Blog | By Theresa Carnegie, Bridgette Keller, David Gilboa, Priyanka Amirneni

On the heels of a nationwide push to regulate pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), Massachusetts enacted a landmark piece of legislation to increase transparency and oversight within the pharmaceutical supply chain, specifically targeting PBMs. Signed into law by Governor Healey on January 9, 2025, the comprehensive bill, titled “An Act Relative to Pharmaceutical Access, Costs and Transparency” (the Act), introduces a multifaceted approach that aims to reduce prescription drug costs, enhance data transparency, and impose stronger oversight of PBMs and pharmaceutical manufacturers.

Read more
Read less

News & Press

Read less

podcasts

Podcast Viewpoint Image

Health Law Diagnosed – New Year's Gratitude

February 3, 2025 | Podcast | By Bridgette Keller, Alison H. Peters, Samantha Kingsbury, Theresa Carnegie, Joanne Hawana , Abdie Santiago, Stephnie John, Pamela Polevoy, Karen Lovitch , Jean D. Mancheno, Deborah Daccord, Rachel A. Alexander, Jane Haviland, David Gilboa, Kathryn Edgerton, Hassan Shaikh, Madison Castle, Laurence Freedman, Priyanka Amirneni, Samantha Hawkins, Tara E. Dwyer, Rachel Yount, Sophia Temis, Xavier Hardy

Host Of Counsel Bridgette Keller invites the Mintz Health Law team to reflect on what they’re grateful for as they prepare for the year ahead. Hear from a dynamic group of Members, Of Counsel, and Associates as they share their perspectives on what’s coming up over the horizon.

Read more
Podcast Viewpoint Image

Mintz Health Law: What We Are Grateful For

January 11, 2023 | Podcast | By Bridgette Keller

Bridgette Keller speaks with the Mintz Health Law team about what they are grateful for as they look back on a year of client service, mentorship, and working together as a team.

Read more
Read less

Events & Speaking

Speaker
Apr
28
2026

AHLA Health Plan and Managed Care Law Institute

Drug Pricing in 2026: Trump Rx and Other Developments

Virtual

Speaker
Jun
29
2020
Webinar Reference Image
Speaker
Moderator
Chair
Speaker
Nov
13
2017

Pharmacy Benefits and Pharmaceuticals: State of the Industry Update

AHLA

Marriott Chicago Downtown, Magnificent Mile, Chicago, IL

Moderator
Speaker
Speaker
Nov
12
2015

4th Annual Pharmacy Benefit Oversight & Compliance Conference

CBI

16770 North Perimeter Drive Scottsdale, AZ

Read less

Recognition & Awards

  • BTI Consulting Group: Client Service All-Star (2020)

  • Chambers USA: District of Columbia (Up and Coming) – Healthcare (2014, 2015); District of Columbia – Healthcare (2023 - 2026)

  • Legal 500 United States: Recognized for Healthcare: Service Providers (2024)

  • Nightingale’s Healthcare News: Outstanding Young Healthcare Lawyers (2005)

  • Phi Beta Kappa

Read less